Authorities in Inglewood this week scrambled to piece collectively a timeline of the violent Parking lot altercation outdoors SoFi Stadium that left a San Francisco 49ers fan in a medically induced coma days earlier than The metropolis Is about to host the Super Bowl.
Inglewood Mayor James T. Howeverts on Friday introduced that Bryan Alexis Cifuentes-Rossell, 33, of L. a. had been arrested on suspicion of felony assault in Reference to the incident.
The injured fan, 40-yr-previous Daniel Luna, was hospitalized after he was found bleeding in a stadium Parking lot about half an hour into the Rams-49ers NFC championship showdown Sunday, authorities said.
The incident drew quick and widespread comparisons to the brutal beating of San Francisco Giants fan Bryan Stow at Dodger Stadium in 2011.
Bryan Alexis Cifuentes-Rossell was arrested on suspicion of felony assault.
(Inglewood Police Division)
However authorities and authorized specialists say that what occurred at SoFi is completely different and in some strategies extra difficult than that case, with Howeverts on Friday indicating that Luna might have been the aggressor.
So far, the minutes main As a lot As a Outcome of the altercation are murky, and no movies have been made public.
Based mostly on Howeverts, investigators have reviewed footage that seems To level out Luna first shoving Cifuentes-Rossell from behind. Cifuentes-Rossell then responded by pushing and placing Luna Inside the face, inflicting him to fall and hit his head.
“The fact Is that this was a … two-shove, one-punch altercation,” Howeverts said all by way of a information convention Friday. “The biggest damage was carried out beset off he landed on the again of his head on the pavement.”
The Occasions requested a quantity of specialists to weigh in on how the extreme-profile incident might play out.
Louis Shapiro, a excellent L. a. protection lawyer, said Cifuentes-Rossell’s lawyer will in all probability start by getting “A clear forensic video that reveals everyfactor that occurred, and interview everyone about what was said earlier than the punch was thrown.”
Based mostly on Howeverts, the footage reviewed by investigators reveals people mingling Inside the Parking lot when Luna pushes The completely different man, who was sporting a yellow jersey believed to be a Rams jersey, from behind.
Luna was sporting a white jersey “that some assume was a throwagain 49ers jersey,” Howeverts said. Pals have confirmed that Luna is a 49ers fan.
The completely different man then pushed Luna and struck him Inside the face, Howeverts said. Luna fell to The beneathside and hit his head.
Shapiro expressed concern thOn the mightor was “saying on a excellent platform the defendant assaulted the sufferer” but famous that many elements might affect the case, collectively with Luna’s blood-alcohol diploma, Cifuentes-Rossell’s actions after the punch, and whether or not any verbal threats have been made between The lads.
Nonetheless, Cifuentes-Rossell’s legal professionals are More probably to argue that “the grave Outcome right here was not a foreseeable event from the one punch,” he said.
His largest drawback Could be his actions afterward.
“The drawback is he fled the scene after. If he’d stayed and gotten assist for the man, that isn’t going to be as drawbackatic,” Shapiro said.
Based mostly on Howeverts, police traced Cifuentes-Rossell‘s tackle from the license plate of a automotive captured on surveillance video Contained in the stadium lot. Police left contact information at his house.
Cifuentes-Rossell later contacted police but declined To return to the department to be interviewed, Howeverts said. Officers then went to his office in Montebello, and he “voluntarily accompanied them to the Inglewood Police Division” and was taken into custody.
Luna, who was taken to Harbor-UCLA Medical Center on Sunday after being found bleeding Inside the stadium Parking lot, stays Inside the coma. Ought to he die, Shapiro said, the case would in all probability Discover your self to be Definitely one of voluntary manslaughter.
Howeverts Wouldn’t say whether or not Luna would furtherly face costs for the altercation, noting “Which Could Even be As a lot As a Outcome of the district lawyer’s office.”
“They will Take A look On the totality of the circumstances, They typically’ll make their choice,” he said, including that it doesn’t seem from the video footage that anyone else was involved Inside the altercation.
Greg Risling, a spokesman for The l. a. County district lawyer’s office, said Friday that no costs had been filed and Did not Reply to A question about whether or not Luna might face costs as properly.
Howeverts said Cifuentes-Rossell’s arrest was tied to “assault by A method To current good bodily damage.” Based mostly on the California penal code, such a conviction might Finish in a quantity of yrs’ imjailment, a nice, or each.
Cifuentes-Rossell was launched in lieu of $30,000 bail at 1 a.m. Friday, Howeverts said. It was not immediately clear whether or not he has obtained authorized illustration, and makes an try To Obtain him Friday have been unsuccessful.
Lara Yeretsian, a felony protection lawyer who has recurrented extreme-profile consumers, collectively with convicted killer Scott Peterson, said she believed Luna was technically the aggressor, and The quantity of strain Utilized by Cifuentes-Rossell “Isn’t out of proportion.”
“As horrible As a Outcome of it sounds, A great lawyer will argue That is typically a fluke factor,” she said. “As his protection lawyer, I might say he was not overdoing it by delivering one punch. Regulation enstrainment typically decides whoever has Probably the most accidents is the sufferer, And that is not the law.”
Also beneath scrutiny is SoFi itself. Two law enstrainment sources with information of the stadium said some parts of the tons don’t have full digital camera safety. A lot of The safety Is concentrated inside and immediately Throughout the stadium, and the parking tons are left to people directing visitors, they said.
These sources said the stadium has been inspired To usher In further L.A. County sheriff’s deputies to complement safety after inner considerations arose thOn tright here was not enough law enstrainment to police typically drunk and indignant followers. L.A. County Sheriff Alex Villanueva said final week that he has assigned 380 personnel to the Super Bowl.
David Lira, a member of the authorized group that recurrented Stow after the 2011 beating at Dodger Stadium, said rivalry video recreations typically draw followers with intense satisfaction and extreme feelings, and that it’s important for stadiums to have strong safety plans in place.
“They knew a rival group was coming into metropolis,” Lira said. “They Want to have adsimplyed their safety plan for this particular recreation. It’s An exact recipe for disaster, till You’ve The proper protocols in place.”
Even Contained in the stadium, movies have emerged in current months displaying fights between followers.
Former federal prosecutor Neama Rahmani said the incident at SoFi had echoes of what occurred to Stow at Dodger Stadium.
In that case, Louie Sanchez pleaded responsible to a felony rely of mighthem and was sentenced to eight yrs in jail. Marvin Norwood pleaded responsible to assault by means More probably To current good bodily damage and was sentenced to 4 yrs behind bars.
However prosecutors Inside the case had proof thOn the pair delivered a quantity of blows to Stow, collectively with full “wind-up kicks” to Stow’s head that Outcomeed in a mind damage, Rahmani said.
“Prosecutors [Inside the SoFi incident] are very restricted right here in whOn They will allege, and they anticipate to face a protection constructed round self-protection and that it wasn’t the accused’s intent to set off good bodily damage,” Rahmani said.
Howeverts said it was inaccurate to liken the incident at SoFi to what occurred to Stow.
“The state of affairs in Dodger Stadium is nowright here Similar to this,” he said, “and to be blunt about it, it Appeared like a small altercation that went very dangerous …. It wasn’t Similar to you had people ganging up on somebody and beating them.”
The mightor furtherly said a safety guard referred to as paramedics very shortly after the altercation. He said he was not involved about safety at SoFi Stadium.
“I’m very snug tright here was enough safety,” Howeverts said. “You’re not going to cease every altercation and argument That occurs between followers. It’s simply not going to happen.”